Kitchen Dorks is reader-supported. When you purchase via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports: Helpful Buying Tips

best-ice-cream-makers-consumer-reportsMaking ice cream at home sound like an unrivaled gourmet experience, but you might be thinking it is a complicated task that won’t be easy to accomplish. In reality, you can easily create the flavorful scoops of ice cream by simply putting the required ingredients inside a bowl.

The best ice cream makers are available in the market to provide gelato, slush, frozen yogurt, and any standard stuff you want to make. Making ice cream at home seems very exciting, but you still require some guidance to pick the best item.

Our detailed guide and reviews on best ice makers’ consumer reports are purposely composed to assist you in this regard.

5 Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports

Nowadays, the ice makers have made life easier by quickly doing their job without creating any mess. Anyone can easily make ice cream by operating the machine efficiently by just pushing a button. So, enjoying flavorful ice creams at home isn’t difficult these days.

To necessitate all the hard-core ice cream lovers, our researchers and the team of experts have gathered some of the best ice cream makers’ consumer reports to give the finest suggestions. In this article, you will find the five best ice cream makers with premium quality and an affordable price range.

Cuisinart 1.5 Quart Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream Maker

Highlighted Features 

Weight: 10.3 Pounds

Dimensions: 10.75 × 10.75 × 15 inches

Material: Polypropylene

Capacity: 1-1/2 Quartz

Freezing Time: 20 minutes

Warranty: 3 Years


Whether you are a beginner or an expert in making ice cream, the ice maker by Cuisinart is the supreme option for you. Many professionals and experts highly recommend this due to its reliability and remarkable functioning.

The dynamic motor works rigorously to mix ingredients with its paddle, while the fully insulated freezing bowl has enough space to blend everything with equal consistency. An expert has stated, “ I usually prefer less pricey freezing items, but this one is incredible and least expensive.”

While another commented, “This ice cream maker freezes ice faster than I thought.”

“Making frozen desserts was never easy for me before trying Cuisinart 1.5 Quartz Ice Cream Maker, but it delivers me the delicious ice cream within 15 minutes.”

Things We Liked 

  • Transparent lock lid
  • Nonslip feet at the base
  • Perfect for drinks and desserts
  • Powerful motor
  • Dual-insulation on the freezing bowl

Things to Consider

  • Bowl needs to freeze for 24 hours before use.

Cuisinart ICE-30R Pure Indulgence 2-Quart Frozen Yogurt-Sorbent Ice Maker

Highlighted Features 

Weight: 2.3 Pounds

Dimensions: 10.5 × 10.88 × 16 inches

Material: Material

Capacity: 2 Quartz

Freezing Time: 20 minutes

Warranty: 3 Years

Cuisinart ICE-30R Pure Indulgence

Not just an ice cream maker, Cuisinart ICE-30R is also the best for making frozen yogurt. Its stunning design and excellent performance help attain the ideal results to make delectable ice creams. All you have to do is add the required ingredients to its large bowl, and within less than 20 minutes, there will be only soft and sweet dessert to enhance your cravings.

One consumer reported, “ I was astonished to see how this machine works perfectly to make the best quality ice cream. I have never imagined this could be so easy with this ice cream maker.”

To get the best outcome, you will have to follow the recipe properly, and then the ingredients will turn into a soft texture. You won’t get rock-hard dessert out of its freezer within seconds. Even without a compressor, it makes ice cream within minutes at such a low price.

Things We Liked 

  • Automatic indulgence with mixing paddle
  • Easy cleanup
  • Smooth operation
  • Premium quality motor
  • Stylish design

Things to Consider

  • Must wash by hands; not safe for dishwasher.

KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker

Highlighted Features 

Weight: 6 Pounds

Dimensions: 10.9 × 10.3 × 10.3 inches

Material: Plastic

Capacity: 2 Quartz

Freezing Time: 25 minutes

Included Components: Freezing bowl, drive assembly, and dasher

Warranty: 1 Year

KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment

You don’t need to spend money on buying a new ice cream-making machine if you have a KitchenAid at your home. This mixer includes drive assembly, a freezing bowl, and a paddle to make the process easier and more efficient.

After chilling the bowl for 15 to 20 hours, you can adjust the settings to stir and churn the ice cream within 25 minutes. After keeping it in the freezer for an hour, you will get a gelato texture. It produces low noise, and the bowl is quite large for making enough ice cream.

Consumers mentioned the easy operation and quick setup of the mixer. At the same time, some suggestions were also given regarding better results, such as freezing the dasher at room temperature, which may melt down your cream, turning off the microwave, or anything that can possibly raise the kitchen’s temperature.

After using the machine, store it in the freezer to keep it in good condition for a longer time.

“The quality of the ice cream was superior. It was rich, creamy, thick, and flavorful.”

Things We Liked 

  • A mixer that fits perfectly with KitchenAid ice cream maker
  • Easy usage and maintenance
  • Sleek & compact design
  • Better mixing with dasher
  • Quiet operation

Things to Consider

  • Freezing is not consistent.
  • No option for auto shut off.

Cuisinart ICE-70P1 Cool Creations Ice Cream Maker

Highlighted Features 

Weight: 13.5 Pounds

Dimensions: 9.74 × 8.62 × 13.22 inches

Material: Brushed Chrome

Control Panel; LCD Display

Countdown Timer: Automatic shut off

Capacity: 2 Quartz

Freezing Time: 20 minutes

Included Components: Measuring cup and recipe book 

Warranty: 3 Years

Cuisinart ICE-70P1 Cool Creations 2-Quart Soft Service

Cuisinart has been popular among ice cream-making brands for a long time, while the Cuisinart ICE-70P1 is also included in the list of top best ice makers consumer reports.

There is an LCD to give access to the operating options on the front screen. Varying settings for making gelato, sorbet, and ice cream are available on the panel to give your a variety of delicious items. The automatic shutting-off system allows you to turn off the ice cream maker once your ice cream is prepared.

A removable cup has also been included in its parts that act as a measuring cup to ensure the right quantity of ingredients is added to the machine.

According to the reports, this model, among other Cuisinart ice cream makers, is the least noisy and much faster than ICE-30. The quick speed delivers ice cream faster, and it is very easy to get ice cream out of it. Most users found this machine fast, easy to use, and clean.

Things We Liked 

  • Countdown timer and LCD screen
  • Manual modes
  • Auto shut off
  • Integrated measuring cup

Things to Consider

  • The freezing bowl is heavy in weight.

Hamilton Beach 68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker

Highlighted Features 

Weight: 5 Pounds

Dimensions: 15.3 × 12.5 × 11.1 inches

Material: Metal

Capacity: 4 Quartz

Freezing Time: 20 minutes

Warranty: 3 Years

Hamilton Beach 68330N

Along with ice cream, you can also make frozen yogurt, sorbet, sherbet, gelato, and custard in this amazing ice cream maker by Hamilton beach. You need to add ingredients, water, rock salt, and ice into the bowl while the auto-setup does the remaining task for you.

This one comes with a larger capacity of 4 quarts that you can utilize for large gatherings for some ceremonies or spontaneous celebrations. To create the chilling surroundings, you will need to add rock salt and ice manually as it doesn’t include a freezing bowl.

“After taking this ice cream maker out of the box, we started the process of making ice cream within minutes. It was so easy to use, just like a plug-&-play operation.

Many consumers lauded that this machine has the simplest and automatic function that performs well to meet all the needs of ice cream lovers.

Users have also said, “you put all the ingredients in it, walk aside, and your tasty ice cream is ready when you come back.”

To keep it running for a long time, wash and clean everything properly by hand and then freeze it.

Things We Liked 

  • Lid that can lock easily
  • Large bowl
  • High capacity of 4 quartz
  • Completely automatic in functions
  • Easy to use and clean

Things to Consider

  • There is a need to add layers of ice and rock salt manually.

Things to Consider While Choosing Best Ice Cream Makers According to Consumer Reports

Mostly the ice creams we buy include preservations to enhance the shelf life, which is indeed harmful to health. To keep yourself in good health and have the fun of making ice cream for your whole family, buying an ice cream maker is the best solution. You must keep the following things in mind.

Design & Quality

The essential features that should never be overlooked are the design and manufacturing quality of the ice cream maker. In our list, we have combined all the functions as well as beautifully designed machines, while the flimsy or easily breakable ice cream makers aren’t included.

There must be a paddle to give the ice cream a good texture and mix all ingredients evenly; a dosing hole should also be present.

Size & Usage Benefits

You should always go for an item that doesn’t take much space, have a quiet operation, and be lightweight to move around the place easily. 1.5 and 2 Quartz are sufficient to serve medium to large families.

An ice cream maker should also have an easy way to use, from getting the machine ready to operate to assembling all the parts to make the ice cream. By having a good ice maker, you can get rid of the hassle of preservations and enjoy mouthwatering ice cream at your home.

Overall Performance

You can make several other things from one ice cream maker machine, such as slush, sorbet, gelato, and frozen yogurt, without spending money on buying additional components.

As your multitasks can be done simply by an ice cream maker, you should get one with a timer to reduce the work stress and make it more fun to make ice cream at home.

Speed & Texture

To get the ice cream quickly, your ice cream maker must have fast speed as the whole day will take to keep the bowl inside the freezer in order to make the next batch. So you must check the speed mentioned in the manual before buying it.

The ice cream maker must have a slow speed for a thicker texture, while the swift pace will be good enough to make the thin texture. This variety of textures is available in frozen bowl ice cream makes. However, for a better experience, one can rely on a compressor for making ice cream.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it worth investing in ice cream makers?

An ice cream maker is a great investment if you are a die-hard fan of ice creams. You can make tons of ice cream with your machine, and that homemade ice cream will be totally healthy for you.

How long does an ice cream maker take to make ice cream?

Usually, it takes almost 20 to 40 minutes to make ice cream, but this can be only possible if you have already frozen the bowl. The process of freezing boil may take 12 to 24 hours in some cheaper models. However, you must freeze the bowl right now to eat ice cream tomorrow.

Final Thoughts

Nothing can be comparable to the joy of having a chilled cup of delicious ice cream on a fresh hot day and made keeping all hygiene in check. We are hopeful that you will find this worthy to help you make the right decision by narrowing down your search for the best ice cream makers’ consumer reports.